icon-account icon-glass

Popular Products

The Lean Protein
Whey protein powder for weight-loss.
The Energy Booster
Pre/intra-workout powder with BCAAs.

Here’s How To Choose The Best Milk Alternatives For You And The Planet

18th November 2021

18th November 2021

By Beth Shelper

There are plenty of reasons that people choose to switch to a vegan milk, ranging from the milk alternatives health benefits, their reduced environmental impact, and even their taste. But when it comes to choosing the best non-dairy milk for you, the healthiest milk alternative, or even the best non-dairy milk for coffee, it can become a bit challenging to choose between the many, many milk alternatives on the market.

We’re here to break it down. We’re talking taste, sustainability and more. It’s the battle of the non-dairy milk alternatives, if you will. But first, as always, let’s get the basics out the way.

What are non-dairy milks?

Non-dairy milks are a group of plant-based milks such as oat, cashew and coconut milk, that are made without the need for dairy milk from cows. This means that not only are their environmental impact much lower, but that they are great for those that want to follow a vegan lifestyle and remove animal by-products from their diet. They’ve also got some pretty sweet health benefits, too.

What are the benefits of non-dairy milks?

Of course, the health benefits of non-dairy milks vary from milk to milk, but broadly, some of the great benefits of dairy milk alternatives include:

  • Great sources of calcium
  • Cholesterol free
  • Easier to digest
  • A delicious taste
  • Fewer calories

Due to the increasing popularity of dairy milk alternatives, too, you’re spoilt for choice when it comes to brands, milk types and even flavours. For this reason, here at Innermost we recommend that if you try one dairy milk alternative and don’t like it – maybe you don’t like the taste or texture, just try another one! You’re sure to find one that you love.

It can be pretty overwhelming when selecting the best milk alternative, though. So let’s take a look together…

What is the most sustainable milk alternative?

It’s a fact that in general, plant-based milks are more sustainable. Their production uses less land, less water and their production leads to far fewer levels of greenhouse gases than dairy milk counterparts.

The two most sustainable milk alternatives are soy milk, who’s production requires the least amount of water, and almost milk, who’s production leads to the least carbon dioxide. So, if you’re looking to make the swap to a dairy-free milk in the hope of making a sustainable dietary choice, soy or almond are the milks for you.

What is the best non-dairy milk for protein shakes?

When it comes to choosing the best non-dairy milk for protein shakes, you’re looking for a delicious taste and a creamy texture. Both of which are provided by almond milk.

Almond milk has a similar, creamy consistency to cows milk which is ideal for creating thick and satisfying protein shakes, and the vitamin content of this milk packs a punch, too. Almond milk contains Vitamin A, Vitamin D and Vitamin E, which is a great addition to your protein shake, for sure. For those that love a caffeine boost, almond milk is often considered the best non-dairy milk for coffee, too!

If you’re looking for a great tasting dairy milk alternative to add to your shakes, though, we really recommend coconut milk. Sweet and delicious, coconut milk is a firm cult favourite for protein shakes, especially with our pineapple flavoured product The Energy Booster… did someone say Pina Colada?

What is the healthiest milk alternative?

If you’re thinking of making the switch from dairy milk to plant milk, it’s probably fair to say that one of the biggest motivators behind this choice is the health benefits. Maybe you’re lactose intolerant and fed up of the milk-induced bloating, or perhaps you’re just conscious of the high fat content that dairy milk can bring…

Whilst these are worthy concerns, when deciding on the healthiest milk alternative, it’s important to consider the sugar content of your brand of choice. That’s what you should be looking for.

Soy milk is one of the most popular dairy milk alternatives, and it’s not hard to see why. As one of the healthiest on the market, soy milk contains just as much protein as cows’ milk, and as long as the milks don’t contain any added sugars and are unsweetened, soy milk is definitely the healthiest pick.

Summary

There are a few really key points to consider when making the switch to a dairy milk alternative. Firstly, non-dairy doesn’t mean non-delicious. Many people opt for a dairy milk alternative for the taste and difference that these milks can bring to smoothies and protein shakes as a result, for example.

Secondly, switching to non-dairy milks is a great choice for the environment. The dairy industry has a hugely detrimental affect on the environment, and so switching to one of these delicious alternatives is a great way to reduce your environmental impact.

By the way… why not make the change this World Vegan Day? Whether you opt for oat milk, soy milk, almond milk, or any other of the worthy plant-based milk alternatives, let us know what you think! Head on over to @liveinnermost. We’d love to hear from you.

Product Spotlight

Need Expert Advice?

Other Insights

I've Been Taking Creatine Every Day For Six Years
Something happens in March. The people who started strong in January, the ones with the new routine, the new kit, the renewed sense of purpose, are now splitting into two groups. The ones who've lost momentum. And the ones asking sharper questions. Not "what should I take?" but "what actually works?" Creatine keeps coming up. And every time it does, I notice the same pattern: people either swear by it without really understanding why, or they assume it's something bodybuilders use and leave it alone.I've been taking it every single day for six years. So let me tell you what I actually know. Why I started I didn't start taking creatine for the reasons most people assume. I wasn't trying to get bigger. I was training consistently, eating well, and hitting a wall. That frustrating place where effort stops translating into progress. A friend with a sports science background told me creatine was the most researched supplement in existence. More peer-reviewed studies than almost anything else on the market. That got my attention. So I started. And I kept going. What I noticed The first week, nothing dramatic. But over the following three to four weeks, something shifted. I could push a little harder. An extra rep. Slightly more on the bar. Training sessions that didn't end in the usual flat feeling of having nothing left. Those are marginal gains. They don't feel significant in the moment. But they compound. Over months, they're the difference between a plateau and real, measurable progression. The one time I stopped, about two years in, during a stretch of heavy travel where I got lazy about it, I felt the absence more than I expected. Not immediately. But within a few weeks, training felt duller. Less sharp. I put it back in and haven't looked back since. I also noticed something I hadn't anticipated: my thinking felt clearer on the days I trained hard. I assumed it was the exercise. I later learned creatine may have had something to do with that too. What creatine actually does Most people think of creatine as a muscle supplement. That's not quite right. What creatine does is help your body regenerate ATP, adenosine triphosphate, more efficiently. ATP is your cells' primary energy currency. It's what your muscles burn during intense effort. But it's also what your brain runs on. Here's the mechanism: during high-intensity exercise, your body depletes ATP rapidly. Creatine stored in muscle tissue, in the form of phosphocreatine, allows you to replenish that ATP faster. That's why creatine consistently improves performance in short, explosive efforts: weightlifting, sprinting, high-intensity intervals. But the same ATP recycling process happens in the brain. A growing body of research suggests creatine may support cognitive performance, particularly under conditions of stress or sleep deprivation. A 2021 study published in Scientific Reports found meaningful improvements in memory and cognitive function following supplementation. It's not a nootropic in the trending sense of the word. But the evidence is real, and it applies to more people than the gym crowd. The effective dose is well established: 3 to 5 grams per day, taken consistently. No loading phase required. No cycling. Just daily consistency, and that's where most people go wrong. What the industry does instead Creatine monohydrate has been around for decades. That's a problem for brands that need something new to sell. So new formats appear. Creatine HCL. Buffered creatine. Kre-Alkalyn. Creatine ethyl ester. Creatine gummies. Each one marketed as superior: faster absorbing, more bioavailable, easier on the stomach. The evidence doesn't support it. Multiple head-to-head comparisons, including a widely cited review in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, found no meaningful performance advantage for alternative creatine forms over monohydrate. In some cases, the alternatives perform worse per gram of active compound. In the case of creatine gummies, several brands including some very large ones have been shown not to contain the creatine concentrations they claim on the label. What you actually want is simple: a clinically relevant dose of creatine monohydrate, taken every day. That's it. What I use The Power Booster is 100% pure creatine monohydrate, nothing added, nothing unnecessary. Five grams per serving, which sits right at the evidence-supported daily dose. It's not complicated because it doesn't need to be. The science on creatine monohydrate is already settled. The job is just to take it consistently. (If you have a friend still on the fence about creatine, forward this their way. It's one of those rare supplements where the evidence is clear enough to just recommend without caveats.) Read more
The Ingredient We Almost Didn't Put In The Energy Booster
There's a question we ask about every ingredient before it goes into a product. Not "is this trending?" Not "does it look good on the label?" Just: does the evidence actually support putting this in? Most of the time, that question is straightforward. Either the research is there or it isn't. But occasionally you land on an ingredient where the science says yes and something else gives you pause. That's where formulation gets genuinely interesting. Beta alanine was one of those decisions. What Beta Alanine Actually Does Most people who've taken a pre-workout have felt beta alanine without knowing it. It's the ingredient responsible for the tingling sensation you get in your face, your neck, your hands. That feeling has a name: paraesthesia. It's harmless. But it's also the reason we nearly left beta alanine out. Before I get to that, the science. Beta alanine is a non-essential amino acid. On its own, it doesn't do very much. But inside muscle tissue, it binds with another amino acid called histidine to form something called carnosine. And carnosine is where the real work happens. During intense exercise, your muscles produce hydrogen ions as a byproduct of energy production. It's the build-up of those hydrogen ions, not lactic acid as most people think, that causes the burning sensation and the drop-off in performance. Carnosine acts as a buffer. It mops up those hydrogen ions and delays the point at which fatigue kicks in. The research on this is substantial. A 2012 meta-analysis published in the journal Amino Acids, covering over 40 studies, found that beta alanine supplementation consistently improved exercise capacity, particularly in high-intensity efforts lasting between one and four minutes. The effect size was meaningful and reproducible. This wasn't a promising pilot study. It was a decade of accumulated evidence pointing in the same direction. In practical terms: more reps before failure. More output before you hit the wall. Sustained performance over a longer window. So why the hesitation? The decision we almost got wrong The tingling. Not because it's dangerous. It isn't. The paraesthesia from beta alanine is a well-understood pharmacological response and there is no evidence of harm at the doses used in supplementation. But we had a real concern: if someone takes The Workout Blend for the first time and feels an unexpected tingling in their face, and nobody told them it was coming, we've just lost their trust. Possibly permanently. The easy path was to leave it out. Plenty of pre-workout formulas do exactly that, either because they're being cautious or because they want a smoother consumer experience. No ingredient, no explanation required. We talked about it a lot. And the conclusion we kept coming back to was this: removing an ingredient with strong evidence because it might confuse people is not how we want to make formulation decisions. That's the same logic that leads brands to include ingredients with weak evidence because they're more familiar, more comfortable, more sellable. The answer wasn't to remove it. The answer was to be upfront about it. The tingling means the beta alanine is working. It's a real physiological response to a real ingredient doing a real thing. If we believe in the science, we include the ingredient and we explain what's happening. That felt like the right standard to hold ourselves to. What the rest of the market does Most pre-workout formulas fall into one of two categories.The first is the stimulant-heavy formula. Stacked with caffeine at doses that produce a short spike, a noticeable crash, and not much else underneath. These sell well because the immediate sensation of energy feels like evidence that something is working. It often isn't, not in any meaningful physiological sense beyond what caffeine alone would do. The second is the proprietary blend. A long list of ingredients with no disclosed amounts, making it impossible to know whether any of them are present at doses that match the research. Proprietary blends let brands list an ingredient without committing to a dose that would actually work. Both approaches optimise for perception. Neither optimises for performance. What I'd recommend The Energy Booster (soon to be renamed to The Workout Blend) contains beta alanine alongside citrulline malate, which supports nitric oxide production and blood flow during training, BCAAs at a 2:1:1 ratio to safeguard lean muscle, and natural caffeine from guarana for sustained energy without the spike you get from synthetic sources. The formulation is built around what the research supports at doses that match the evidence. If you feel the tingling the first time you take it, that's the beta alanine. It's normal, it fades within 20 minutes or so, and it's a sign the formula is doing what it's supposed to do. Read more